11 things medical shows always get wrong, according to doctors
- Medical TV shows often portray medicine in an unrealistic way.
- Doctors on TV frequently use a defibrillator on a flatlined patient but, in reality, this never happens.
- The endless paperwork and the high cost of medical care are rarely portrayed on TV.
Medical television shows are filled with drama, romance, and life-and-death situations. Though these shows can be exciting, they're often not representative of what really goes on in hospitals.
INSIDER consulted with doctors, nurses, and other medical professionals to uncover what TV shows get wrong about practising medicine.
You wouldn't actually use a defibrillator on a patient whose heart has stopped.
It's a common scenario on medical shows: A patient flatlines and a team of doctors rushes to revive them by using jolts of electricity from defibrillator paddles. It sounds plausible, but it's actually totally inaccurate.
"The defibrillator only works on specific heart arrhythmias. Asystole (a.k.a. flatlines) is not one of them. This always makes me laugh when I watch TV or movies. You only defibrillate ventricular tachycardia and ventricular fibrillation," Dr. Snehalata Topgi of ParaDocs Worldwide told INSIDER.
A defibrillator is definitely a life-saving device for certain cardiac emergencies, but doctors wouldn't use one on a flatlining patient because there is no electrical activity in their heart to "reset" into a normal heart rhythm with the device.
In reality, CPR isn't a miracle worker.
Contrary to what you might see on TV, it's rare for a doctor to completely revive a patient with cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). Though CPR is still one of the best things a bystander can do if someone's heart stops beating, it's not an instant cure.
"The point of it is to keep blood flowing to the brain until blood circulation and breathing can be restored at the hospital. Many times this 'miracle worker' is a temporary fix and once the CPR stops, the patient is back on death's door," said Dr. Topgi.
The reality of CPR's effectiveness is much grimmer than what is shown on TV. Although exact statistics are varied, according to a 2016 study, The American Heart Association reports that CPR saves one life for every 30, with a 10% decrease in survival with each minute of delay.
Paperwork is a much bigger part of medical life than is shown on TV.
In real life, doctors aren't only spending their time treating patients - tons of charting and paperwork also comes with the job.
"Doctors likely spend a good chunk of time not just examining patients but completing a ton of paperwork. Medical shows often depict a lot of scenes of doctors taking care of patients, but really overlook the numerous hours spent on administrative tasks," physician and health expert Dr. Nesochi Okeke-Igbokwe told INSIDER.
For example, a primary care doctor might spend a good portion of each day completing forms for patients, calling insurance companies for authorizations, or talking to pharmacies about patient prescriptions.
Diagnosing a rare problem usually takes longer than depicted on television.
Doctors on medical shows often seem to diagnose rare conditions based on just a few conversations with the patient or a simple blood test. Though common illnesses might be readily diagnosed within a few hours, it's not always that simple.
"Medical shows also tend to speed diagnoses to fit them into the confines of the TV show, often allowing rare conditions to be diagnosed with relative ease," Dr. Amesh A. Adalja of Johns Hopkins Centre for Health Security told INSIDER.
In many cases, it's not likely that a single doctor or test will be able to pinpoint the problem at a glance.
Unlike on television, doctors don't spend much time at bedsides.
Medical shows often show doctors and surgeons sitting with patients at their bedsides, monitoring their vitals, and helping them walk around after treatment. In real life, however, nurses and other medical staff take care of the majority of bedside care.
"Medical shows that portray the doctor as the primary care provider at the bedside are out-of-date. Many of the tasks that doctors are shown doing in television shows such as starting IVs, giving medications, assisting in codes or other emergent situations, or getting patients out of bed and walking around are actually done by nurses or other staff members, Amy Witkoski Stimpfel, registered nurse and assistant professor at NYU Rory Meyers College of Nursing, told INSIDER.
Medical shows don't usually capture the range of providers that are responsible for patient care, from nurse practitioners and physician assistants to respiratory therapists, pharmacists, nutritionists, and occupational and physical therapists.
Real doctors aren't constantly flirting with each other on the clock.
On some medical shows, romantic encounters in the hospital between medical staff are commonplace. But in real life, doctors aren't relentlessly flirting in operating rooms or meeting up in supply closets.
"Hospital romances do exist. However, the majority of these physician couples keep their personal relationship outside of the hospital setting and for the most part maintain high standards of professionalism while at work," explained Dr. Okeke-Igbokwe.
There is a code of professional conduct and official regulations governing staff behaviour at every hospital or medical centre. Most doctors adhere to and respect these rules of professional behaviour.
It's not acceptable for real medical staff to hook up with patients.
Hospitals and medical centres have explicit rules governing the relationships between healthcare providers and patients. Doctors on TV might flirt with their patients, but real-life doctors almost certainly don't.
"There is just so much that can go wrong. This happens but shouldn't, especially with respect to the legal aspects. It is also very unprofessional," said Dr. Topgi.
Pursuing a romantic relationship with a patient has the potential to compromise care and lead to serious legal ramifications.
Pregnant people don't always give birth right after their water breaks.
What's known as "water breaking" is actually the tearing of the amniotic sac surrounding the baby (also called the rupture of membranes) that usually occurs prior to the onset of labor or regular uterine contractions. Though people on medical shows are often shown immediately going into full labor mere moments after their water breaks, this isn't normally the case.
"This is true sometimes. But other times, doctors have to artificially break a person's amniotic sac during labor or it happens on its own way before it should during the pre-term time period," said Dr. Topgi.
According to BabyCentre, only 60% of people start having contractions within 24 hours of their waters breaking. Most of the other 40% go into labor within 48 hours. Though it's not unheard of for people to give birth an hour or so after the amniotic sac ruptures, many births take much longer.
Bedside manner actually matters much more in real life.
On TV, doctors sometimes use a "tough love" approach to get patients to commit to treatment or even argue with patients over personal matters. In real life, this kind of behaviour would be grounds for dismissal.
"The blatantly rude and non-existent bedside manner of some doctors on television dramas would definitely not fly in real life. Yelling and acting obnoxiously towards your patients would likely leave you jobless, no matter how brilliant of a clinician you may be," said Dr. Okeke-Igbokwe.
Real doctors have specialities – they can't do it all.
On TV, it's not unheard of for an emergency room doctor to scrub in for surgery in order to save their ailing patient. In real life, most doctors are highly specialized and usually handle a limited range of conditions.
"Medical shows often do not respect the specific scopes of practice of different medical specialities and subspecialities. For example, you have non-surgeons performing surgery, surgeons managing conditions that cardiologist would be managing, and the like," explained Dr. Adalja.
Medical shows don't show the high cost of medical care.
It's rare that medical programs show patients filling out reams of insurance paperwork. The healthcare systems in many countries, however, can mean that patients are often saddled with massive medical bills as a result of their treatment.
"Medical costs are the number one reason for personal bankruptcy in the US. Most patients who visit a hospital or doctor's office deal with insurance and have to pay a copay. These medical shows never show this side to healthcare," Suzanne Garber, co-founder of digital hospital network Gauze, told INSIDER.
This is a real-life part of healthcare that isn't normally depicted in television shows.
For more, go to Business Insider South Africa
Receive a single WhatsApp every morning with all our latest news: click here.
Also from Business Insider South Africa:
- South Africa's 'number one' chips: McCain forced to withdraw claim after Steers fights back
- You may soon get credit from TymeBank - and 5 other things to know about Patrice Motsepe's bank
- Oprah Winfrey avoided at least a R550 million loss after unloading bunch of her Weight Watchers shares at a perfect time
- This phone's battery is so big, you can talk on the phone for 3 days straight on a single charge
- You can now get tekkies that look like avocado toast
- Rain could beat cellphone network giants Vodacom, MTN, Cell C and Telkom to 5G