Property shares have fallen 28%, industrial companies lost 20% and banks bled almost 6%. Mining stocks have been the only notable winners – gaining a blistering 2% so far this year.
Michele Santangelo, portfolio manager at asset manager Independent Securities, has crunched the numbers and found that almost 96% of JSE shares are now down 10% from their highest point in the past year:
The losses are in part due to international factors, says Santangelo. Emerging markets across the world have been under pressure due to US president Donald Trump’s trade wars, specifically given fears that Chinese economic growth could be weakened. This could weigh on global emerging market sentiment and hurt demand for South African resources in particular.
Higher interest rates in the US have made returns from South Africa look less enticing in comparison and has reversed investment inflows into South Africa, in turn hurting the rand.
Another major factor was the massive 28% fall in the Chinese tech giant Tencent. South African company Naspers – which represents a fifth of the JSE’s value - owns more than 30% of Tencent.
Santagelo says political uncertainty and land expropriation talk have also made foreign investors nervous.
“Primarily though, it’s the low growth on offer in South Africa – compared to both developed and emerging markets – that have weighed on the equity market.”
South African shares are now relatively cheap. On average, shares listed on the JSE is trading at a forward price earnings ratio of 12.6 times. (The price earnings ratio calculates what investors are willing to pay for a rand of the company’s profits. The forward PE is calculated by dividing the share price by expected earnings).
This is below the historical average of 14 times – and as recently as 2015, SA shares were trading at 17 times.
Smaller companies are even cheaper: The JSE’s mid-cap index is trading at a forward PE of only 11 times, compared to 17 three years ago
Historically, when cash returns are better than shares over a prolonged period, this provides a strong indication that future returns from shares will improve dramatically , says Santangelo. The JSE has basically not delivered any returns over the past five years – and has not kept up with inflation at all.
But a pick-up in share prices is not a sure-fire bet. Much will depend on the G20 meeting this week, and whether China and US could calm trade tensions, says Santagelo.
“Investor confidence in the JSE could strengthen as South Africa improves its fiscal situation and state-owned enterprises mend their ways. The elections next year will be decisive.”
He sees value in quality blue chip stocks that took a hit over recent months: particularly Richemont, Anheuser, "Shoprite, Coronation and Mondi stand out," he adds.
“If you are willing to take on a bit more liquidity risk in the small/mid cap sector, I would look at (supply chain group) Santova, Advtech and KAP Industrial which are now showing decent value.”
Also from Business Insider South Africa: