This was the worst CA exam in five years - but embattled audit firm KPMG delivered the most top performers
- This year's past rate for the gruelling final chartered accountancy exam was 68% - the lowest in five years.
- Nearly one-third of the 3,037 trainee accountants who sat for the exam failed.
- A prestigious list of 12 candidates who demonstrated exceptional performance is dominated by KPMG trainee accountants.
Being a chartered accountant opens all kinds of doors in corporate South Africa - almost 40% of South Africa's CEOs are chartered accountants. The average JSE-listed business has more than 2 CAs(SA) on its board. But becoming one is not easy: It involves some seven years of studying towards a degree majoring in accounting, a post-graduate course focusing on the theory of accounting, signing a training contract with an auditing firm and, then, two gruelling exams, the initial test of competence and final assessment of professional competence (APC).
A total of 3,037 candidates sat for the APC in November 2018, which the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (SAICA) says is the highest figure recorded.
In February 2019, only 2,080 received good news that they've passed their final assessment and are now a registration away from using the coveted CA(SA) designation next to their names.
The 68% pass rate was however, the lowest in five years.
Some 2,529 were taking the APC for the first time, while 508 were repeating the assessment. More than 72- first-timers and nearly half of the repeaters failed the APC, making it the highest number of failed candidates in a long time.
Almost 48% of the 1,219 black candidates that took the APC failed - compared to the pass rate for coloured (73%), Indian (78%) and white (86%) candidates. .
The lower pass rate is "a reflection of various factors including the significant increase in the number of repeat candidates who sat in November, as well as the quality of prospective CAs(SA) coming out of South Africa’s disruptive tertiary environment," says Mandi Olivier, SAICA's senior executive of professional development.
"While, on the face of it, it [declining pass rate] may seem negative," Olivier says "it is proof of SAICA’s continued commitment to producing CAs(SA) of the highest standard."
"What is particularly satisfying," adds Oliver, "is the number and diversity of the 12 candidates who earned a place on SAICA’s prestigious APC honours roll," which includes three from embattled audit firm, KPMG.
KPMG has more South African-based candidates on the honours roll than any other firm. According to SAICA, the honours roll is made up of candidates who demonstrate exceptional performance and show the greatest insight into the way they complete the case study tasks.
While it also had three candidates, two of Deloitte's candidates were doing their learnerships with its London office. Nedbank was second with two candidates in top 12.
KPMG has been embroiled in various auditing scandals for work relating to Gupta-related entities, the South African Revenue Service and VBS.
SAICA says it will be engaging with audit firms as well as professional programme providers to identify the reasons behind the drop in pass rates.
For more, go to Business Insider South Africa.
Receive a single WhatsApp every morning with all our latest news: click here.
Also from Business Insider South Africa:
- This shocking graph shows how SA company profits have disappointed investors
- Discovery is paying R23 million a month to rent its shiny new head office, which has a roof-top running track
- Watch: A failed South African rocket launch ends with a spectacular bang
- These South African magnetic field barriers stop sharks 100% of the time - and they’ve just been installed in Reunion
- Everything you need to know about South Africa's massive gas find
- The 20 best Budget tips for Tito Mboweni - including free Lotto tickets for those who pay their Eskom bills on time