Business Insider Edition

A US citizen lost a bitter custody battle with her Saudi ex-husband over their 4-year-old daughter, exposing the harsh realities of the kingdom's legal system

Bill Bostock , Business Insider US
 Jul 15, 2019, 02:00 PM
LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 07:  Saudi Crown Prince Mo
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. (Photo by Leon Neal/Getty Images)
  • A US citizen embroiled in a legal battle with her Saudi ex-husband over their daughter has lost - laying bare the Kingdom's archaic legal system.
  • Bethany Vierra, a Washington state native moved to Saudi Arabia in 2011 and married a Saudi in 2013. They divorced in 2017 and have been embroiled in a bitter dispute over custody of their daughter Zaina, 4, since.
  • Vierra's story came to prominence after The New York Times reported husband Ghassan al-Haidari was using his power as Vierra's legal guardian to prevent her leaving the country with Zaina.
  • On Sunday a Saudi judge ruled Vierra's video evidence - allegedly showing al-Haidari taking drugs in front of Zaina - was worthless as it was not witnessed by a man.
  • Her husband's other defence was that he swore to Allah he did not commit any offences. This was sufficient for the judge, who ruled Zaina would live with al-Haidari's mother, who lives in the same house.
  • INSIDER understands Vierra has 30 days to appeal the ruling, and will do so.
  • For more stories, see www.businessinsider.co.za.

A custody battle between a US citizen and her ex-husband over their 4-year-old daughter in a Saudi court has exposed the harsh realities facing women in the country's legal system.

On Sunday, a Saudi judge granted custody of 4-year-old Zaina, the daughter of Washington state native Bethany Vierra, to ex-husband Ghassan al-Haidari's family.

The ruling was made despite video evidence allegedly showing him verbally abusing her and taking drugs in front of the child.

Vierra was granted a divorce from al-Haidari in 2017, and has been engaged in a bitter legal battle with the Saudi businessman since November 2018.

On Sunday the judge ruled Zaina would reside exclusively with her grandmother because Vierra wasn't a Muslim and because evidence allegedly showing al-Haidari smoking hashish wasn't valid as it had not been witnessed by a man.

The judge said in his ruling: "Since the mother is new to Islam and a foreigner in this country and embraces customs and traditions in the way she was raised, we must avoid exposing Zaina to these traditions."

The case highlights both the Kingdom's opressive guardianship system and difficulties women face in the courts.

Under the system, women are considered second-class citizens and have the same rights as children. Women need male permission to leave the home, get married, and to travel abroad.

Vierra's story rose to prominence after The New York Times reported al-Haidari was using his power as Vierra's legal guardian to prevent her leaving the country with Zaina.

On Sunday, the judge disregarded evidence against Vierra's husband because he swore to Allah he had not committed an offence.

Vierra's husband had previously used his power as her legal male guardian to prevent her from taking Zaina to visit family in Washington state.

Last week Saudi Arabia hinted it would amend the guardianship law pertaining to women needing permission to leave the country, after a global backlash to the government's Absher app, first revealed by INSIDER.

Vierra moved to Saudi Arabia in 2011 to teach at a women's university. While there, she met al-Haidari. They married in 2013 at a destination wedding in Portugal. Vierra now runs a yoga studio in Riyadh.

Receive a single WhatsApp every morning with all our latest news: click here.

Also from Business Insider South Africa:

  • Indicators
  • JSE Indexes
15.35
0,53%
18.69
0,22%
17.05
0,46%
$1,507.30
0,8%
54280.80
-0,19%
DAILY BUSINESS INSIDER UPDATE

Get the best of our site delivered to your inbox every day.

Sign Up