We took a closer look at the daily deals at One Day Only and Takealot – and found some dubious discounts
- One Day Only, and Takealot's Daily Deals sub-site advertise deep discounts on popular products.
- But our investigation found that the discounts are often not as big as advertised.
- One Day Only has been reprimanded – twice - by the advertising regulator.
The daily deal has become a feature of online shopping in South Africa, with One Day Only, and Takealot.com's Daily Deals sub-site offering deep discounts on popular products.
The two companies advertise discounts, typically upwards of 30%, on 50 or more products each day. The discounted products change daily, and the emphasis is on urgency - campaigns around each site push customers not to miss out on the dramatic, soon-to-disappear deals.
But as consumers have pointed out on websites like HelloPeter.com, the deals are often not as big as advertised, and One Day Only has also been reprimanded – twice - by the advertising regulator last year.
The Advertising Standards Authority ruled against One Day Only in the cases, saying the company distorted the retail prices of products in order to make the discount look greater than it actually is.
One Day Only said that the discounts are based on retail prices determined by the buying team. It said the advertised retail price, on which the discount is based, “does often exclude the short-term marketing specials of other online discount stores” and that they include “where possible a survey of traditional retail stores”.
Takealot includes details on its list prices in its terms and conditions. It says the list price advertised is suggested by the supplier or third-party seller of the relevant product. Where this is not available, “an estimate may be provided”.
Although both One Day Only and Takealot Daily Deals do offer many items at legitimately discounted prices, we found several examples of overstated pricing.
In some cases, the product was available on a competitor sites for the same price or cheaper.
One Day Only
The following are examples of dubious offers on One Day Only:
- A wireless karaoke microphone selling for R299. They advertised the product with a 57% discount, excluding shipping, off a claimed retail price of R700. The supplier, Gimmicks and Gizmos, is selling the same product on its website for R495, excluding shipping. This equates to an actual discount of 39.5%.
- A magnetic car mount for cellphones selling for R169, at a 44% discount off a claimed retail price of R300. The same product is selling without a discount on Digicape for R199.
- A decorative lamp selling for R189, at a 37% off a claimed retail price of R300. The supplier sells the same product on its website for just R6 more than One Day Only’s discounted price. This equates to an actual discount of 5.6%.
- A Bright Star ceiling fan selling for R1,599, at a discount of 50% off a claimed retail price of R3,200. Takealot is selling the same fan, without a discount, for R1,939. One Day Only’s deal is just 17.5%, not 50% cheaper, than the product available elsewhere online.
- A double pole telescopic clothes line selling for R419, at a 48% discount. Takealot is selling the same product, without a discount, for R435.
- A case of Striped Horse Lager for R299 - a claimed discount of 29%. On the same day, BottleShop was selling the same product, without a discount, for just R14 more.
- In an example of One Day Only actually being more expensive than the competitors, they sold a bluetooth music receiver for R199, which they claimed came with a 43% discount. On the same day, Takealot was selling the same product for R177 (since increased to R178).
Takealot Daily Deals
We also found doubtful Takealot discounts.
- A Bosch drill advertised as part of their Daily Deals was selling for R499 at an advertised discount of 28% off the claimed retail price of R699. Kloppers is currently selling the drill at the same price, without a discount.
- A Bosch cordless screwdriver was selling for R549 - with a discount of 38% from a claimed list price of R899. On the same day, Loot was selling the same screwdriver for R652, discounted by 19% from a claimed list price of R805. Hardware Centre was selling the same product for R569, which they claim is discounted from R739.
- A Weber fireplace, selling on a Daily Deal for R1,799 - a 48% discount off the claimed retail price of R3,499 - is listed on the official Weber website at R2,799.00. The actual Daily Deal discount is therefore 35.7%.
- A chainsaw selling on a Daily Deal for R2,799 - a 13% discount off the claimed retail price of R3,250, is selling on the Kloppers website for R2,499
- One of the biggest deals on this particular day for Takealot was a Berlinger Haus casserole pot. The selling price was R389 - 61% discount off the claimed list price of R1,010. The official Berlinger Haus website in South Africa has the same product selling for R499*.
How to get an actual good deal
In the past, One Day Only has argued that their competitors often match their discounts on the day of the sale. This does not explain how many of the inflated retail and list prices are often in direct conflict with the official supplier websites.
Include in the equation the flat rate of shipping, at least R55 with OneDayOnly, and the discount is further eroded. In some cases, the shipping cost is the discount difference, and in others it brings the product back up to its actual retail price.
One Day Only responded to the offers we identified by saying that “Wherever possible, we take the retail price directly from our suppliers. It allows us to run their products at a discount determined by their list price”.
In cases where the seller is unable to supply a retail price, One Day Only’s buying team does “comparative market research” the day before the deal in order to establish a retail price.
Takealot says that they strive to offer their customers “the best prices that we are able to, however there will be cases when another retailer can offer the product at a lower price.”
It’s clear that until there is legislation governing the advertising of listing prices, the onus rests on users to conduct due diligence on each item, without feeling pressured into the sale.
* Update: The original version of this article mis-stated the price of the Berlinger Haus casserole pot on the official Berlinger Haus website. It is, in fact, available for R499, not R49 as originally reported. Business Insider apologises for the error.
In response to questions from Business Insider on some deal examples, Takealot provided a statement that reads, in full:
At Takealot.com, our goal is always to offer customers great products at great prices. To understand how our RSP is determined it is important to distinguish between the List Price, Normal Selling Price and the Deal Price.
The List Price is the recommended retail selling price suggested to us by the supplier of the relevant product.
The Normal Selling Price is the price that the product is then sold for on the site. This price varies, depending on whether a product is subject to a promotion or if newer versions of a product become available.
The Deal Price falls under our Daily Deal promotions which are run every day on our site. Various products on site are subject to this promotion and are sold at a discounted rate
In respect of Daily Deals and other discounted goods, the discounts are calculated against the List Price and not the normal selling price. We always strive to offer our customers the best prices that we are able to, however there will be cases when another retailer can offer the product at a lower price. Of course the reverse is also true in the instances when our price is lower.
For more, go to Business Insider South Africa
Receive a single WhatsApp every morning with all our latest news: click here.
Also from Business Insider South Africa:
- This is how the price of a cappuccino in South Africa compares to the rest of the world
- A flood of Chinese screws, nuts and bolts has hit South Africa – now government may strike back
- You can now get tekkies that look like avocado toast
- Cape Town homeowners hit by steep new municipal valuations - even Cyril Ramaphosa has been affected