Covid-19 antibodies seem to disappear after only a few months in many people - why you shouldn't panic
- We don't know how long coronavirus antibodies last.
- Recent research from Spain suggests they may disappear in some patients in a matter of weeks.
- Other studies suggest antibodies last a few months.
- Here's what we do know so far about the life span of coronavirus antibodies and what it means for immunity and potential vaccines.
- For more stories go to www.BusinessInsider.co.za.
Among the many lingering questions about the coronavirus, one of the most crucial is: How long do antibodies last?
With some diseases, like measles and hepatitis A, infection is a one-and-done deal. Once you get sick and recover, you're immune for life.
"For human coronaviruses, that's not the case," Florian Krammer, a vaccinologist at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, told Business Insider. "You can get repeatedly infected once your immunity goes down."
Increasingly, research is starting to coalesce around an unfortunate picture of Covid-19 immunity: People who develop antibodies might not keep them for very long.
Last week, research out of Spain suggested that antibodies could last only three to five weeks in some patients. And a preliminary study published Saturday from researchers in the UK showed that antibodies may last less than three months.
Such findings have implications for vaccine development, since the efficacy of a vaccine hinges on the idea that a dose of weakened or dead virus can prompt your body to generate antibodies that protect you from future infection. If those antibodies are fleeting, a vaccine's protection would be fleeting, too.
But even though short-lived antibodies might diminish hopes of achieving widespread or permanent herd immunity, some experts say there's no cause for panic: Our body's immunity isn't just tied to antibodies.
Antibodies may last just a few weeks or months
In April, Dr. Anthony Fauci, the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, hypothesised that people who were recovering from Covid-19 at that time would likely be immune into the fall.
"If we get infected in February and March and recover, next September, October, that person who's infected - I believe - is going to be protected," Fauci said.
But the evidence from the UK study suggests the time frame might be shorter.
The study tested more than 90 coronavirus patients for antibodies over 94 days. They found that three weeks after infection, just 60% of patients had developed a "potent" antibody response. In the weeks that followed, just 17% of those patients kept that level of antibodies, The Guardian reported.
In the other patients, antibody levels declined 23-fold or became undetectable within three months after their infections.
Another study, published in June, found similar results. The researchers tested for antibodies in 37 people who had fallen ill and recovered in Wanzhou, China. They also tested 37 others who had tested positive for the virus but never showed symptoms. About eight weeks after recovery, antibodies dropped to undetectable levels in 40% of the asymptomatic people and in 13% of those who had symptoms.
The recent study on this topic in Spain found that one in five people lost detectable levels of antibodies within five weeks.
That research, published last week in The Lancet, involved 60,000 people in Spain. They were tested for antibodies three times between April and June. About 7% of the participants who had antibodies during the first phase of the study (April 27 to May 11) no longer had them in the second phase (May 18 to June 1), according to CNN. About 14% of participants who had antibodies during the first stage no longer had them by the third phase (June 8 to 22).
Loss of immunity was most common among people who never developed symptoms, Reuters reported.
"Immunity can be incomplete. It can be transitory. It can last for just a short time and then disappear," Raquel Yotti, one of the study's coauthors, said during a news conference.
But Krammer said he was skeptical of the findings.
"It's physically not possible for antibodies to disappear in a matter of weeks," he said.
Krammer said the half-life for immunoglobulin (IgG), the most common antibody found in our blood, is one to three weeks. That's how long it takes for the number of those protective proteins to decrease by half.
"Within weeks, the amount of antibodies you have will be cut in half, not gone," he said.
We don't know what level of antibodies protects us from infection
The problem with studying how long antibodies last is that it's still unclear what level one needs to be considered immune in the first place.
"We do not know how much protection the antibodies may provide or how long this protection may last," the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said.
With many better-studied viruses like measles, Krammer said, "you know how many antibodies you need to be protected."
But we don't have a specific number for the coronavirus.
- Identifying that threshold could be "extremely helpful for vaccine development," Krammer said - that way, researchers conducting trials would know whether their formula is going to work.
But even if antibodies disappear, that doesn't mean a vaccine is useless
The point of an effective vaccine is to produce antibodies in enough people to build up herd immunity within the population. To put the coronavirus in decline, at least 50% of the population would have to be immune, perhaps far more.
But it's not a deal breaker if people become susceptible to reinfection sometime after the initial shot, Krammer said.
"This happens for a lot of vaccines," he said. "It's not a problem. You can get revaccinated."
- That's what booster shots are for. The question, however, is whether follow-up shots will be needed on the scale of months or years.
Your immunity to the virus isn't solely tied to antibodies
There's one other reason that the findings about antibody levels dropping shouldn't cause excessive concern: Your immunity doesn't just depend on these proteins.
White blood cells also have an impressive immunological memory that can help your body identify and attack the invading virus should it ever return. T cells can destroy infected cells, and B cells work to produce new antibodies.
- "If you're reinfected after some time, it would be an attenuated disease. It will be not as severe as the first time because your B and T cells remember the virus and react quickly," Krammer said.
Some research has even shown that not everyone who gets sick develops detectable antibodies, which suggests their response to the virus could be tied up in a different layer of the immune system.
But neither recent study of antibodies - in China or Spain - tested participants to see how many T cells and B cells they developed.
Hilary Brueck, Morgan McFall-Johnsen, and Adam Payne contributed reporting to this story.
Receive a daily update on your cellphone with all our latest news: click here.
Get the best of our site emailed to you daily: click here.
Also from Business Insider South Africa:
- All the new lockdown rules – including mask-free exercising for some
- Steep new tariff hikes for Joburg, Tshwane and other cities, while Cape Town faces less pain
- The rand beat other currencies for a third week in a row
- Presidency deletes announcement that leisure travel will be allowed, says it was an error
- Gautrain still plans 18 more stations - but money is tight due to Covid-19